On 19 March last
year, the ADU website carried the following NEWS ITEM. It was among the first
to break the news of this ornithological disaster.
'SAFRING ringer,
Claudia Holgate, is currently aboard the M/V Prince Albert II, a cruise ship to
the Antarctic. She reports: "On Wednesday 16 March 04h30 the cargo ship Oliva
ran aground on Nightingale Island close to Tristan da Cunha.
Because our arrival in the area was within 24 hours, our ship was informed by
local authorities and asked to assist. On Thursday afternoon we conducted a
rescue operation with our zodiacs to get the 10 remaining crew off the vessel.
At 02h30 on Friday morning (yesterday), the ship split in half."
'Currently there
is an oil slick spreading, and there are reports from Nightingale Island of
Northern Rockhopper Penguins coming out of the sea covered in oil. Claudia reports:
"The spill could not have happened at a worse place."
'The Oliva was a
75 300 tonne cargo ship carrying soya beans from Brazil to Singapore, and was carrying about
1500 metric tons of heavy fuel oil. The ship ran aground at Spinners Point, the
NW corner of the island. There are many species of birds that are only found in
this area and a major oil leak may have catastrophic consequences to the bird
life around these islands. Nightingale
Island and the closeby Middle Island
host breeding populations of seabirds numbered in millions. Another potential
problem is rats finding their way from the sinking ship onto the island and
this is a real threat to burrow nesting birds. A salvage tug, the Smit Amandla,
was dispatched from Cape Town
on 17 March, and is expected to arrive on 21 March. The distance from Cape Town is about
2000 km. On board the tug is Estelle van der Merwe, who was in charge of
SANCCOB at the time of the Treasure oil spill, and she is working in close
collaboration with SANCCOB.
'More news,
especially as it relates to oiled birds, will follow here as it becomes
available.'
Well, a news
blackout was pretty rapidly imposed. And very little information emerged at the
time. But now at last, the final report from the shipping investigation has
been released. This maritime safety document deals with what can only be
described as the head-on collision between the bulk carrier Oliva and Nightingale Island. The wreck produced a massive oil
spill in the Tristan da Cunha group. The
51-page document can be downloaded here.
Here are some of the summarizing points in the report.
• Oliva ran
aground because the planned course the vessel was following on the plotting
sheet was found to have taken the vessel directly over Nightingale Island.
• Although the
bridge team was aware that the vessel would be passing close to some islands,
it was not aware as to when that event would take place.
• Although the
vessel did not have BA chart 1769, other appropriate available charts covering
the area had not been used.
• Both the second
mate and chief mate were not aware that the vessel was heading towards Nightingale Island. This was because there was no
indication on the plotting chart to alert them of the dangers ahead.
• Both the second
mate and chief mate saw some echoes on the radar screen, but did not
investigate them and dismissed them as rain clouds.
• There was no
suitable mark placed across the ship's track to indicate the need to change to
a hydrographic chart.
• Neither officer
had consulted BA chart 4022. Although this chart was of an unsatisfactory
scale, it could have prompted them to adopt a precautionary approach when radar
echoes were sighted on the radar.
• The combination
of the cold, the medication, lack of sleep, the time of the day and reaction to
the vessel's grounding suggests that the chief mate was probably not fit to
stand a navigational watch.
• Although the
company had provided comprehensive guidance and procedures in its SMS to
prevent this accident, these were not followed on board.
• The passage
plan did not comply with the company's instructions of clearing distances when
a vessel was in open waters.
• The master made
no reference to the passing of Islands in his
night orders. Reference to the Islands, could
have alerted the second mate and chief mate to the significance of radar
echoes.
• The handing
over checklist required the chief mate to establish the proximity of any
hazards to the vessel. This appears not to have happened and he relied on the
brief hand-over he received from the second mate.
• The chief
officer did not check the position which the able-bodied seaman plotted on the
chart.
Gosh, what a
disgrace – this is a disaster which was ridiculously preventable.